14 July 2021
Topic of the day
ECHR urges Russia to allow same-sex marriages
Moscow, July 14, Interfax - The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) has found that Russia violates the right to private life enshrined in the European Convention on Human Rights by refusing to allow same-sex marriages.
"As regards same-sex couples, the Court reaffirmed that they were just as capable as different-sex couples of entering into committed relationships, with a need for formal acknowledgment and protection of their relationship. It was incumbent on the States to take that into account, and to strike a balance between their needs and those of community at large," the ECHR said in a statement.
Three same-sex couples went to the ECHR, as they have given notice of their intention to marry at their local registry offices in Russia, but their applications have been rejected for more than ten years. Muscovites Irina Fedotova and Irina Shipitko argued before Moscow's Tverskoy District Court in 2009 that the refusal to accept their notice to marry violated their rights under the constitution and the convention. Their claim was declined because, among other things, the court found that marriage had to have the "voluntary consent of a man and a woman." That court ruling was upheld on appeal.
The couple appealed to the ECHR, which combined their claim with the similar cases of residents of the Lipetsk Region - Dmitry Chunusov and Yaroslav Yevtushenko v. Russia and Elmira Shaikhraznova and Yelena Yakovleva v. Russia. The ECHR found that Russia has violated Article 8 of the convention (the right to respect for private and family life) in relation to these applicants. At the same time, according to the judgement, the court cannot explicitly impose an obligation on the country to acknowledge same-sex marriages, but believes that the authorities need to reach a compromise.
"The Court reiterated that Article 8 did not explicitly impose on States an obligation to formally acknowledge same-sex unions. However, it implied a need to strike a fair balance between the competing interests of same-sex couples and the community as a whole. [...] In particular, regarding the argument that a majority of Russians disapprove of same-sex unions, the Court stated that access to rights for a minority could not be dependent on the acceptance of the majority," the ECHR said in its ruling.
The court reiterated that giving the applicants access to formal acknowledgment of their couples' status in a form other than marriage would not be in conflict with the "traditional understanding of marriage" prevailing in Russia, or with the views of the majority to which the government referred.
Page: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 |
- Idea to return criminal liability for homosexuality is logical - Orthodox human rights activist 10 January 2014, 17:10
- Russian Orthodox Church supports debate on anti-sodomy law 10 January 2014, 13:09
- Rights defenders say Okhlobystin's idea to put gays in prison is obscurantist, odious 10 January 2014, 11:54
- Russian LGBT community does not expect "sodomy" article to be restored in Penal Code 10 January 2014, 11:42
- Russian cellphone trader not to fire manager for seeking gay sex re-criminalization 10 January 2014, 10:14
- Georgian patriarch asks Europe not to impose alien ideas on nation 07 January 2014, 14:15
- Ukraine not prepared to legalize same-sex "marriages", as demanded by EU - Azarov 16 December 2013, 10:00
- Minsk administration bans public events organized by sexual minorities 11 December 2013, 10:05
- Russia to oppose inclusion of sections on sexual orientation in intl documents 10 December 2013, 10:02
- Elton John performs in Moscow, protests homophobia 09 December 2013, 10:01
- Homophobia should not be created in society - Putin 21 November 2013, 10:05
- Moscow perplexed with U.S. demands for review of IOC opinion on Russian gay propaganda law 15 November 2013, 13:21
- Georgian Patriarchate against LGBT-sponsored shelter for homeless children 15 November 2013, 12:53
- Russia did not violate intl law by banning homosexuality propaganda among minors - children's ombudsman (updated) 14 November 2013, 16:30
- Attempt to link Russia-EU visa talks with position of sexual minorities absurd - diplomatic source 07 November 2013, 10:05
- Protesters: pact with EU to mean Ukraine's "homosexualization" 06 November 2013, 10:01
- Putin says Olympic Games participants, guests, including sexual minorities, will be comfortable 29 October 2013, 10:25
- Police detain 67 LGBT activists at rally in central St. Petersburg 14 October 2013, 10:09
- Orthodox supporters of gay propaganda penalty thwart Moldovan parliament's meeting 11 October 2013, 11:38
- Ban on gay propaganda won't affect sexual minorities' rights - Naryshkin 02 October 2013, 10:02
- There are no laws in Russia that punish sexual minorities - Putin 20 September 2013, 11:42
- Russian court upholds ban on planned LGBT events 19 September 2013, 10:02
- Meeting between Obama, LGBT activists in Russia is double standards - diplomat 09 September 2013, 11:30
- Duma to consider bill depriving gay parents of parental rights 05 September 2013, 11:11
- Gay activist asks for meeting with Putin 04 September 2013, 13:18