04 October 2006, 14:05
An issue of Constantinople’s primacy does not infringe unity between the Orthodox Churches on major theological problems - Moscow Patriarchate’s representative
Moscow, October 4, Interfax - The controversy over Constantinople as ‘an Orthodox Vatican’ surfaced at the Orthodox-Catholic meeting in Belgrade does not infringe unity of the Orthodox world on major theological problems.
The secretary for interchristian relations of the Moscow Patriarchate Department for external church relations Rev. Igor Vyzhanov gave an interview to NG-Religii newspaper published on Wednesday. He was a member of the delegation of the Russian Church at the 9th meeting of the Joint Commission on Theological Dialogue between the Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholic Church held in Belgrade recently.
‘I must tell you that unity between the Orthodox Churches on the major dogmatic and theological problems exists in principle. An issue of ‘primacy and honour’ which Constantinople has recently interpreted in a peculiar way, stands by itself,’ the priest said.
According to him, this is an ecclesial-political matter that is often examined from ‘dogmatic angle.’
He explained that participants in the Orthodox-Catholic meeting differed on par. 45 of the document on the authority of the Ecumenical Councils, and in particular on ‘parallels’ between ‘communion with Rome’ for the local Churches in the West and ‘communion with Constantinople’ for the Orthodox Churches.
‘Actually, it was a question of the two centres, as we do not regard the Patriarchate of Constantinople as a centre of the Orthodox world! It enjoys primacy by honour, and nothing more. It is neither ‘Orthodox Rome,’ nor ‘Orthodox Vatican,’ Rev. Igor underscored.
He noted that the President of the Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity cardinal Walter Kasper served as moderator at the session at which par. 45 was discussed. Seeing differences between the Orthodox, he suggested that the Orthodox should ‘sort it out among themselves’ and that the paragraph be crossed out as a compromise. The co-chairman of the meeting Metropolitan John of Pergamon (Patriarchate of Constantinople) insisted on keeping the paragraph and moved that a vote be taken. Kasper as moderator seconded his motion.
The representative of the Russian Orthodox Church to the European Institutions Bishop Hilarion of Vienna and Austria lodged a protest.
‘Bishop Hilarion objected against Kasper’s being under Constantinople’s thumb, as it is simply impossible to put ecclesiological problems to the vote. These problems should be resolved among the Orthodox at the top level rather than at the Orthodox-Catholic theological commission,’ the priest added.
According to him, the document discussed in Belgrade was presented as a ‘convergent statement,’ i.e. a declaration on that what unites us.
‘All paragraphs in the document that provoked differences between the sides were amicable deleted. All controversial points can be removed from a document, yet they will not escape from our life,’ the Russian Church’s representative said in conclusion.
- Constantinople refuses to sever communion with Russian Orthodox Church 19 October 2018, 15:20
- Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia cuts ties with Constantinople 19 October 2018, 14:31
- The Ukrainian metropolitan: Constantinople abandoned God 19 October 2018, 13:07
- Putin about nuclear war: we'll go straight to paradise, while they will simply pop off 19 October 2018, 10:58
- St. Andrew's Church in Kiev to stay property of state - press service for Sophia of Kiev National Sanctuary Complex 18 October 2018, 18:43
- Ukrainian Orthodox Church disagrees with transfer of St. Andrew's Church to Constantinople 18 October 2018, 18:41
- Ukrainian parliament supports transfer of St. Andrew's Church in Kiev to Constantinople 18 October 2018, 14:36
- Media review: Metropolitan Hilarion: "The fact that the Patriarchate of Constantinople has recognized a schismatic structure means for us that it itself is now in schism" 18 October 2018, 13:22
- Leaders of non-canonical churches of Ukraine differ on 'autocephaly' issue – media 18 October 2018, 11:03
- Ukrainian Orthodox Church disproves forecasts of mass exodus of its clergy, congregation to Constantinople's church 18 October 2018, 11:00
- Metropolitan Alexander (Drabinko) who proclaimed himself Constantinople cleric says each Ukrainian orthodox bishop should choose whose side to belong 17 October 2018, 10:12
- Russian Orthodox Church planning to address issue of pastoral direction for Russians on territory of Constantinople Patriarchate (updated) 16 October 2018, 19:08
- Dodon proposes hosting Pan-Orthodox Council in Moldova 16 October 2018, 18:00
- Peskov: Kremlin concerned by relations between Russian Orthodox Church and Constantinople 16 October 2018, 15:47
- Poroshenko to propose granting Constantinople permanent use of St. Andrew's Church in Kiev 16 October 2018, 13:57
- Russian Orthodox Church takes path of self-isolation - Poroshenko 16 October 2018, 13:10
- Holy Synod of Russian Orthodox Church appoints new bishops to administer parishes in Europe, U.S 16 October 2018, 11:45
- Ukrainian Orthodox Church leader attended Russian Synod meeting, supported its decision - Metropolitan Hilarion 16 October 2018, 10:14
- Belarusian Orthodox Church joins Holy Synod's decision to break up with Constantinople 16 October 2018, 10:10
- Former primate of Orthodox Church in U.S. opposes U.S. policy about church in Ukraine 15 October 2018, 22:24
- Moscow Patriarchate renews calls for Constantinople to refrain from steps undermining Church unity - Russian Synod 15 October 2018, 22:21
- Russian Church hopes Ukrainian believers will not be harassed 15 October 2018, 22:17
- Russian Orthodox Church hopes Patriarch of Constantinople will change his mind on Ukraine 15 October 2018, 22:13
- Further Eucharistic communion with Patriarchate of Constantinople deemed impossible - Russian Synod's decision 15 October 2018, 22:10
- Court throws out Pentecostals' suit seeking agreement with penitentiary service on prison visits in Astrakhan 15 October 2018, 17:56
- Lukashenko blames politicians for events in Orthodox Church 15 October 2018, 15:24
- Holy Synod of Russian Orthodox Church discussing possible response to Constantinople's actions 15 October 2018, 14:30
- Lukashenko promises to support unity of Orthodox faith 15 October 2018, 13:46
- Police release 100 people detained near Kiev Monastery of the Caves on Sunday – media 15 October 2018, 13:43
- Russian Security Council discussed Constantinople decisions on Russian Church in Ukraine on Friday – Peskov 15 October 2018, 13:40